Moody Sleuth

Exploring crime fiction's melancholy detective series.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Writers
  • Challenges
  • About
  • Sleuth News

Reading ‘Round the World – Wrapping Up South America

By Moody Sleuth 2 Comments

Needle in a Haystack by Ernesto Mallo

From Argentina:

Second on my 2014 Global Reading Challenge list for South America, is Ernesto Mallo’s Needle in a Haystack, translated from the Spanish by Jethro Soutar, the first book in the Inspector Lascano series.

Here’s an overview thanks to the Reactions to Reading Blog:

In 1976 Argentina’s Dirty War had begun and its environment of state-sponsored illegal arrests, torture, killing and forced disappearances provides a brutal backdrop for what would otherwise be a simple tale of a policeman investigating a murder. Superintendent Lascano is asked to follow up on a report of two bodies being found but when he arrives at the site there are three bodies. Two are of young people who were clearly killed by the Junta’s death squads and their deaths will not be investigated further but the third body is an older man’s which appears to have nothing to do with the others. It is this death that Lascano decides to investigate…

A quick read, Needle in a Haystack progresses, as the above quoted review later mentions, as something of a ‘literary jigsaw’ with pieces from various points-of-view, and with a non-sequential time line that adds to the puzzle.

While I did enjoy the idea of this ‘puzzle’ aspect, I found the actuality of it a bit confusing.

To be brief, I read it through, mainly because it was short. Aspects of the story, such as the romantic thread involving Inspector Lescano and the young, lovely dissident he ends up harbouring secretly in his home… and the coincidence of her uncanny resemblance to his dearly-beloved but tragically-dead-too-soon wife… did not enhance my reading.

I realize the book was shortlisted for the 2011 Dagger Awards, and this translation from the Spanish by Jethro Soutar has received many good reviews, so I can’t give it bad marks. All I can conclude is that I’m likely not a member of Ernesto Mallo’s intended audience.

On to my third and last stop in South America:

The Neruda Case by Roberto AmpueroFrom Chile I chose Roberto Ampuero’s The Neruda Case, translated from the Spanish by Carolina De Robertis, sixth in the Cayetano Brulé series. (I chose #6 because it ‘begins at the beginning’, relating the story of how Cayetano Brulé began his career as a private detective.)

Here’s a brief overview from Philip K. Jason’s exhilarating review of The Neruda Case from the June 21, 2012 online version of The Washington Independent Review of Books.:

In The Neruda Case, Roberto Ampuero’s first novel to appear in English (though he has otherwise long been published worldwide), the author’s new readers step into the Chilean crisis of 1973. Allende’s socialist-leaning coalition government is under siege and tottering. A military junta is about to put General Pinochet into power.

The aging and severely ailing Pablo Neruda, an Allende partisan, has something nagging at his soul. A young man named Cayetano Brulé, a Cuban by way of Miami now living with his activist wife in Valparaíso (Chile’s second city), meets Neruda at a social gathering. After some brief conversation, the great poet asks Cayetano to a private meeting during which he convinces him to track down, with utmost discretion, a Dr. Bracamonte, whom Neruda had known three decades earlier during a diplomatic post in Mexico City. Neruda seems desperate to discover the doctor’s whereabouts.

Hypnotized by Neruda’s gift of gab, flattery and transcendent personality, Cayetano agrees. It’s clear that the money will be good. However, he is hesitant; after all, he has no experience or skills in sleuthing. Outrageously, Neruda presents him with an armful of Georges Simenon’s Inspector Maigret novels and suggests that he start reading…

Three good reasons to read Roberto Ampuero’s The Neruda Case:

  1. For the twisty mystery introducing Cayetano Brulé, a new (to me) and potential moody sleuth.
  2. For the historical factor – Ampuero drops us into the Chilean Crisis of 1973.
  3. For the eminently believable depiction of Pablo Neruda – the man apparently responsible for launching Cayetano Brulé’s career as a private detective.

I enjoyed The Neruda Case; the story is unusual and thoroughly engrossing; the writing is excellent, particularly the dialogue (Kudos to the translator!), and though I’m not giving Ceyatano Brulé an auto-pass to my moody sleuth list, I’m looking forward to following him through the series.

I’ll leave you with this link to Book Sexy Review’s most excellent review of The Neruda Case, and point you to the Amazon.com page where you can sample the first few chapters.

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Email
  • Print
  • Pocket

Related

Filed Under: Cayetano Brulé, Ernesto Mallo, Inspector Lescano, Reading Challenge, Roberto Ampuero Tagged With: 2014 Global Reading Challenge, Argentina, Chile, South America

Comments

  1. Rebecca says

    December 10, 2014 at 6:43 am

    I’m just catching up as I just finished this year’s Global Reading Challenge. My opinion is the opposite: I adored Needle in a Haystack and was not a huge fan of The Neruda Case. The Argentinian books I read in undergrad have left a much longer-lasting impact than the few Chilean ones I read, so I may be biased. Or it could be the stories about Argentina from my favorite Spanish professor stayed with me more than what I read about Chile. In any case, thanks for joining the Challenge this year and such interesting posts.

    Reply
    • Moody Sleuth says

      December 15, 2014 at 2:58 am

      Congrats on finishing the 2014 Global Reading Challenge, Rebecca. I’m still scrambling!
      Not surprised to learn that you prefer Needle in a Haystack over The Neruda Case. I see that you put Hyland’s Gunshot Road high on your list; that was one I found interesting enough, but didn’t find Emily Tempest all that convincing. But I’ve been reminded again and again, since taking on this challenge and reading so many reviews, that readers are as varied as writers. I accept that some readers want a cracking ‘page turner’ and are not all that interested in character development… while others shy away from anything with a hint of romance. I’m also thinking that the books we studied with a favourite prof are always going to be special; I still get a little buzz of pleasure when I recognize lines from poems or other literary references I studied with particular profs. Maybe I’ll give Argentinian writers another go… next year.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Looking for something?

Top Posts & Pages

  • The Garnethill Trilogy by Denise Mina
  • Detective Sonchai Jitpleecheep in Bangkok Tattoo
  • Sara Gran’s Claire DeWitt

Recent Posts

  • Adrian McKinty’s Sean Duffy Series
  • Van Veeteren contemplates Tarkovsky
  • Van Veeteren – Curing an Aversion
  • John Brady – More Minogue Please
  • Matt Minogue, Clareman… and cracked?

Tags

2014 Global Reading Challenge Asia Athens Bangkok Beck Bingham Brady Britain Brookmyre Carrigan Cuba Dublin Glauser global reading challenge Greece Haritos Harry Hole Havana Iceland Ireland Jo Nesbo Kelly LA LAPD London Mauri Minogue Nesbo Norway Oslo Reykjavik Scotland Sjowall Sonchai South Africa Sri Lanka Stockholm Studer Sweden Swiss Switzerland Thailand USA Wahloo Wales

Copyright © 2019 · Magazine Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.